Are Altered Art MTG Cards Tournament Legal?
Magic: The Gathering (MTG) has been a popular trading card game since its inception in 1993. With millions of players worldwide, the game has spawned a vibrant community and a thriving market for collectible cards. However, as with any collectible market, there are those who look to alter the cards to enhance their value or aesthetic appeal. The question that arises is whether altered art MTG cards are legal in tournament play. This article delves into the legality of using altered art cards in MTG tournaments.
Understanding Altered Art Cards
Altered art cards refer to Magic: The Gathering cards that have been modified or altered in some way. This can include adding new artwork, changing the color scheme, or even altering the card’s dimensions. While some alterations are minor and purely aesthetic, others can significantly impact the card’s gameplay or value.
The Official Position of the DCI
The DCI (Disciplinary Committee of the International) is the governing body for MTG tournaments. According to the DCI’s rules, any card that has been altered in any way is considered illegal for tournament play. This includes altered art cards, as well as cards that have been altered to have different dimensions, or cards that have had their foil coating removed.
Reasons for the Ban
The ban on altered art cards is primarily due to concerns about fairness and consistency in tournament play. Altered cards can give players an unfair advantage by changing the card’s gameplay, such as altering the color of a creature to bypass color restrictions. Additionally, altered cards can create a sense of inequality among players, as not everyone can afford to purchase or create these modified cards.
Community Perspectives
While the DCI’s stance on altered art cards is clear, not all players agree with the ban. Some argue that minor aesthetic alterations should be allowed, as long as they do not affect the card’s gameplay. Others believe that the ban is unnecessary and that players should be able to express their creativity through their cards.
Conclusion
In conclusion, altered art MTG cards are not legal for tournament play, according to the DCI’s rules. While the reasons for the ban are rooted in fairness and consistency, the debate over the legality of these cards continues to divide the MTG community. Whether you agree with the ban or not, it’s essential to adhere to the official rules to ensure a level playing field for all participants.
